Republican Energy Fumble
The Wall Street Journal
by Kimberley Strassel
Politics has its puzzling moments. John McCain and most of the GOP experienced one late last week. That was when five of their own set about dismantling the best issue Republicans have in the upcoming election.
It’s taken time, but Sen. McCain and his party have finally found — in energy — an issue that’s working for them. Riding voter discontent over high gas prices, the GOP has made antidrilling Democrats this summer’s headlines.
Their enthusiasm has given conservative candidates a boost in tough races. And Mr. McCain has pressured Barack Obama into an energy debate, where the Democrat has struggled to explain shifting and confused policy proposals.
Still, it was probably too much to assume every Republican would work out that their side was winning this issue.
And so, last Friday, in stumbled Sens. Lindsey Graham, John Thune, Saxby Chambliss, Bob Corker and Johnny Isakson — alongside five Senate Democrats. This “Gang of 10” announced a “sweeping” and “bipartisan” energy plan to break Washington’s energy “stalemate.” What they did was throw every vulnerable Democrat, and Mr. Obama, a life preserver.
That’s because the plan is a Democratic giveaway. New production on offshore federal lands is left to state legislatures, and then in only four coastal states. The regulatory hurdles are huge. And the bill bars drilling within 50 miles of the coast — putting off limits some of the most productive areas. Alaska’s oil-rich Arctic National Wildlife Refuge is still a no-go.
The highlight is instead $84 billion in tax credits, subsidies and federal handouts for alternative fuels and renewables. The Gang of 10 intends to pay for all this in part by raising taxes on . . . oil companies! The Sierra Club couldn’t have penned it better. And so the Republican Five has potentially given antidrilling Democrats the political cover they need to neutralize energy through November.
Sen. Obama was thrilled. He quickly praised the Gang’s bipartisan spirit, and warmed up to a possible compromise.
Of course, he means removing even the token drilling provisions now in the bill. But he’s only too happy for the focus to remain on the Gang’s efforts, and in particular on the five Republicans providing his party its fig leaf.
Equally gleeful was Louisiana’s Mary Landrieu, the Senate’s most vulnerable Democrat. She had been sweating the energy debate, especially after her vote against more oil-shale production — a position her Republican opponent, John Kennedy, had used against her to great effect. Yet there she was, chummily standing with the Gang of 10 and boasting that she is working with “five Republicans” to “lower prices at the pump by increasing offshore drilling here at home.”
Mr. McCain, who had been commanding the energy debate, was left to explain why he, of all people, wasn’t more enthusiastic about a “bipartisan” effort on energy, especially one that includes “drilling.”
His camp was forced to take refuge in taxes, explaining that their boss couldn’t sign up for a bill that included more. If this is what Mr. McCain’s good friend Lindsey Graham considers “helping,” somebody might want to ask him to stop.
And pity poor Senate Minority Leader Mitch McConnell, who has been working overtime to stanch GOP losses this fall and head off a filibuster-proof Democratic Senate. His dogged efforts to highlight Democratic opposition to drilling has kept energy in the news and laid the groundwork for GOP candidates to use the issue to their advantage.
In the Colorado Senate race, Democrats had christened former GOP Rep. Bob Schaffer “Big Oil Bob” — hoping to smear his oil industry career. “Big Oil Bob” has instead embraced his pro-drilling positions and is pummeling opponent Mark Udall for his antidrilling stance. In recent weeks, Mr. Schaffer has erased Mr. Udall’s lead. Polls show Republican Sens. Norm Coleman (Minnesota) and John Sununu (New Hampshire) both climbing in the polls on the back of strong energy arguments. As two of the GOP’s most vulnerable senators, both might well have run for cover with the Gang of 10. Instead they’re fighting on the merits.
The “bipartisan” Republican senators have undercut these efforts, and boosted Ms. Landrieu. They’ve even put a smile on Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid’s face. He’d been struggling to tamp down the energy debate through November, where he hopes to increase his majority and permanently shelve drilling. He’s now counting on the Gang to fruitlessly continue “negotiations” straight through the Senate’s short September session and solve his problem for him.
Not one of the five Republicans in the Gang is facing a tough election this year. That’s the sort of security that leads to bad decisions. And theirs is the sort of thinking that could leave Republicans in a permanent minority.
Wild Thing’s comment…………
Stupidity par excellence by these 5 Republicans. I can’t believe this. This is what rino’s do best, the screw America to try and make liberals like them. I mean even Paris Hilton knows that McCain is for drilling and then his “little buddy” goes out and makes a deal with the Dems???
This is not an offshore drilling plan, it is an effort to PREVENT serious consideration of rescinding offshore drilling prohibitions. The Congressional prohibition on drilling EXPIRES September 30, 2008, if they do nothing. So they had to throw SOME roadblock in the way.
Just when I thought the GOP finally found their cujones, Lindsey and his “gang” go and cut them off yet again. The Democrat party may be evil but the Republican party is stupid. And unfortunately, evil beats stupid every time.
You can go to link below to contact these Senators and speak your mind.
http://www.senate.gov/general/contact_information/senators_cfm.cfm
I get so tired of Republicans snatching defeat from the jaws of victory.
Pansy Graham’s phone number: (202) 224-5972
And also othe pansy Graham is proudly displaying his “Gang of 10” affiliaiton and this absurd energy bill on his web site.
http://lgraham.senate.gov/public/
Right on the front page listed under Recent Headlines
Thank God for the other House Republicans that squished them last Friday and will keep after this. But what the hell who needs these scrum assclowns like these 10 people in our government. I say forget the “yes we can” BS from the left, this calls for a a GET THE HELL OUT!
.
From Rush Limbaugh transcript from Friday August 8,2008
RUSH:
” I have some news that’s going to anger you, it’s going to chill you. As you know, brave Republicans in the House are continuing their battle to force Nancy Pelosi to bring the Democrats back to have an up-or-down vote expanding the opportunity to drill for oil in ANWR and offshore. They continue to make their points, and they continue to fight. This is an issue, as you know, as I have mentioned it to you, it’s the issue that can change this entire campaign around. Americans are angry, and it’s not just at the price of oil and gasoline. It is the related price increases, everything that happens as a result of that. Food has gone up, practically everything has gone up, airline transportation, everything’s gone up because of the price of oil. The oil is coming down, but it’s a market that’s still fluid, and nobody can predict what’s going to happen. And whether the price continues to come down or not, we’ve gotten a warning here: We need to do what we can to expand our own supply, and the Republicans in the House are doing everything they can to see to it that this happens.”
“However, in the Senate, there is a new bipartisan coalition called the Gang of Ten, five Democrats, five Republicans, led by Senator Lindsey Graham on the Republican side. They have just forged a compromise that basically cuts the Republicans in the House off at the knees, at least temporarily. The Republicans in the Senate have given the Democrats in the Senate everything they want, everything Barack Obama wants in an energy bill. I’ll give you the details when we come back. But just because it happened in the Senate does not mean it’s doom and gloom, does not mean it’s over with, because the Republicans in the House are still fighting this. This is just a Gang of Ten trying to get the Senate moving on this. It’s not an official Senate bill yet. It hasn’t been passed there. But the Republicans on our side caved totally to the Democrat demands on energy in a way that has to have Obama doing cartwheels if he’s heard about it. “
“They’re doing all of this while these brave Republicans in the House are fighting the odds in their own revolution, trying to stop Pelosi and force her back so that we can move forward on a bill that would expand drilling, five Republican senators join five Democrats and basically hand the Democrats everything they want. “
“This is inexplicable. But the Republicans in the House have not signed on to this. This is just ten Senators of that come up with this compromise. The effort here — Ms. Strassel is right, the effort here — is to have a competing bill in the Senate so that nothing on this gets done before the November election, and because the difficulty will be in getting both bills to the floor and getting a compromise version passed, and then go to conference. It’s too much to happen before the election ’cause they’re not going to be in Washington that much, because everybody’s going to be out on their own reelection campaigns. But, aside from all that, it just befuddles me. (sigh) I read this this morning, and said, “This cannot be true,” and yes, it can be. We have a bunch of coward Republicans scattered around both houses of Congress. “
“We’ve got a bunch of Republicans who have been trained by the presidential nominee of their party that the way to advance yourself with the media and in Washington social circles is to agree with Democrats. This is just mind-boggling. We’ll keep you posted on any further developments.”
“If I am for freedom, why should I give away anything? Not saying this is freedom versus tyranny but gosh, folks, if this keeps up we’re going to have tyranny, well I think we do, in terms of property rights and any number of things. So here’s a bipartisan effort that McCain didn’t support. This one included drilling, limitations on drilling, and McCain wants to open up drilling, it’s become his issue, and these five Republican senators last Friday just nuked it, at least in the Senate.”
“Now, this deal, by the way, this Gang of Ten deal, get this. I talked about some of the regulations in this bill that are onerous. Try this. This deal would allow drilling if — if and when — the EPA and PETA and states and cities and counties and the ACLU clear the way. “
“It would put up more barriers to drilling, which is what the Democrats want, because they want no drilling, period. Five Republicans go along with it.”
“Yeah, this did catch McCain by surprise, because it put him in a very ironic situation. McCain has made his bones being the bipartisan guy, working with the other guys, so here’s Grahamnesty (who is McCain, Jr.) and I think he sees this is how McCain got to be who he is. So Grahamnesty says, “Okay, I’ll try it,” and in the process, McCain is saying, “Lindsey, he-he, he-he. (snickering)” So McCain, the only way he could oppose this, is, “I’m not for tax increases, and there are too many tax increases in this bill. That’s not the way.” But it just took the issue away. Well, it hasn’t done it yet because the bill is not passed in the Senate. It’s just an indication we’ve got these five guys. By the way, another explanation.”
” I left off the most important thing to look at. “Folks, I can’t explain it. You can make up whatever explanation you want. They’re stupid; they want good coverage in the media, whatever it is.” Follow the money. Follow the money. Well, in this case, follow the money. Use your imagination, campaign contributions, lobbyists. They’re not up for election this year. They don’t face serious opposition. The answer to almost every question, particularly in politics, can be found at the end of the trail of big bucks.”
….Thank you Mark for sending this to me.
We should all be “makin’ a list, checkin’ it twice, gonna find out who’s naughty or nice…” and vote the naughty ones out come November. What a nice Christmas present! You lose your job.
Do they know how deep the water is at 50 miles off the coasts?
And do they remember what happened when Jimmy “the peanut farmer, son of Lillian and brother of Billy” Carter tried to tax big oil? It got even worse!
Gosh, these idiots are making 10 times what I make and I could make a better decision. You don’t tax big oil!!! Not if you want to keep your country afloat.
I heard the interview with Chambliss on Limbaugh’s show. You needed a barf bag. Some weird sadomasochistic thing is taking place between the Donks and Pugs. The Donks swing the whip and the Pugs squeal. Graham even LOOKS the part. Maybe our mistake in expecting these time-serving pinheads to be better than they are.
The only explanation is that popular culture has squeezed real quality out of everything, especially the quality of politicians. People with backbone, dignity and intelligence don’t want to smear themselves by associating with these feckless clowns. Graham is the perfect example of the problem, and he’s the ringleader in this gang of spitballs.
Sad to say, McCain isn’t blameless, because he either failed to see the jelly in Graham’s head and spine or he took advantage of it for his own reasons. He’s probably wondering what he created.
I’ve watched Graham at hearings on different issues and if I hadn’t known he had an “R” after his name, I wouldn’t have been able to tell him from a Dem.
This has to be one of the most insulting load of BS directed at the American people. But then, it’s becoming increasingly apparent that the ‘elected’ are counting on the perceived ignorance of regular folks. Those days are drawing to a rapid close even with the media trying to keep us uneducated. The internet will win out.
As bassackwards as the demos have been on oil, the new villian of America. Drilling for oil and accessing new oil sites the democrats have given the republicans a super winning issue. McCain has picked up on it and is still ahead of obama on the energy issue.
Then along comes Lindsey Graham and his gang that can’t shoot straight or at least around corners. They give the democrats exactly what they want. What the Republicans want is what they had before Ronald Reagan, a cameo role in the House and Senate and an occasional President every 20 years or so maybe an Eisenhower or Ford and go on from there making no major policy decisions or involved in anything more important that taking out the garbage from the Senate.
Hopefully, there are some republicans that can stop this or Bush will veto any nonsense legislation that might be generated from this group of lightweights who do not know the difference between a volt and a bowling ball.
The “GANG” needs to just admit that they are really Democrat Turncoats like Hagel– I sense parinoia in Washington- SOME Rebublicans are just going to throw themselves under the bus so Obama won’t have too-LOL!
THEY BEEN THERE LONG ENOUGH – WE NEED TO GET NEW REPRESENATIVES IN BOTH HOUSES ! CONSERVATIVES WITH A WORKING BRAIN PLEASE APPLY!!!!
What is so hard to get about drilling for OIL when we got a motherlode of it ?- – SPECIAL INTERESTS LIL GANG OF TEN??? THEY MUST HAVE SOME SAUDI INTEREST IN OIL OR THEY WOULD NOT BE PULLING THIS CRAP!
Didn’t McCain lead the way with these kind of deals with his Gang of 14? Chickens may have come home to roost for him.
Bob grabbed my thought. McCain has done exactly the same thing to fellow Republicans numerous times over the years. Now his own type of politics is biting him in the ass.
I don’t know what the answer is for conservatives. The Republican Party by and large does not really represent us anymore. The only bright lights in years were Ronald Reagan’s presidency and Gingrich’s Contract with America. Other than that and a few individuals, the Republican Party at the national level has been a failure.
Maybe gas lines and 10 gal limits will wake Americans up again.
They are incumbents, I prefer this succinct description of the word, encumbent:
Lying or leaning on something else.
I just received a form answer from Lindsey Grahamnesty. He said he was glad to hear from me. I guess he hasn’t read my e-mail yet.
The solution to all of this is 434 fewer lawyers in the congress.
Lynn, I agree, I try to keep a little list of names from my State and how they handled each thing. I have written to them and the weird and horrible thing is I heard back from the Democrat and not from the Repulican. What the heck is that? How disappointing that is!! LOL I wrote the Republican back and said hey I heard from the Dem and not from you what is up with that. haha
Rhod, I bet your right. If and I do mean IF, McCain did not know about this ahead of time, then McCain has got to be pretty ticked right now with his mini me Lindsay messing with this especially during the campaign.
Good one Rhod.
Yankeemom, I agree, he does not think like a Republican at all.
Mark, “democrats have given the republicans a super winning issue”…they sure have and these jerks messing with it like this are beyond the pale.
Well said Mark.
Cheryl, I agree, this being able to hang around too long just feeds even more into the ” I can do what I want and forget about we the people”. Power hungry and not concerned about our country. So sad and outrageous too.
BobF, yes they have come home to roost and it ticks me off because the timing could not be worse. But then the timing would not be good at any time.
Your absolutely right Bob.
Tom, exactly. This is not a good time for our side of the fence at all or for America either. I pray we get those who hold America in their hearts first and those that don’t we can vote out.
I wish we had ours here in Florida up for re-election this time and could vote them out and get a conservative. I look forward to it when it is possible.
These games these rino’s play is dangerous and they could care less. It is sickening.
Jack good one!
Mark……”He said he was glad to hear from me. I guess he hasn’t read my e-mail yet.”….LMAO yes I bet. I wish they would at least have someone answer even if we had to wait a day or two. I love how you put that.
I agree too about all the lawyers.
BobF and TomR are correct about McCain leading the way with this “Gang of…” and chickens coming home to roost. Lindsey Graham and the other four Republicans have stabbed their own candidate, party, and country in the back. This November will really be a bipartisan election and the worst of all outcomes.
http://www.werescrewed08.com/images/We're%20Screwed%2008%20bumper%20sticker%20proof3.jpg
The country after November.
http://youvebeenscrewed.net/screwed.jpg
The Palmetto State’s U.S. Senator Jim Demint (R) is #1 – not Lindsey Useless! In 2001, the GOPhers had the Oval Office and Congress – majority wise – and played the PC cards and got their RINO asses kicked. I haven’t $ent one penny to the GOP for the first time in my life… The RINOS and DSP anarchists are one in the same!